I’ve written before about the weird grief comments people have, whether it’s the optometrist telling me how bad she felt when Anthony Bourdain killed himself or the bizarre need strangers have to tell me about the death of their pets. And I get it, I really do. We all want to show empathy and as experiential beings we do that by sharing stories we believe gives us common ground. It’s stupid, but it’s why we do it and I usually laugh it off.
However, there is one particular group that I can’t handle.
Not those people in general. Getting a divorce does not make you a bad person. Not even a little.
It’s a very specific sub-group of divorced people: the ones who want to compare their divorce to becoming widowed.
I understand that divorce can be very painful and it could lead to a deep emptiness, a longing, sadness, depression, guilt, self-loathing and a plethora of other hurtful feelings.
But I only understand this in an academic sense. I don’t know what going through a divorce is like because I’ve never been through one. Because I’ve never been through a divorce I have to trust the reports of those who have. I would never in a million years compare my wife dying to someone’s divorce.
Because they’re incomparable.
They can’t be compared because they are not the same thing.
Since this shitty chapter of my life begun I’ve heard from people that they’d prefer to have had their spouse dead than be divorced because it would have been easier.
I want to break that down for a second because here’s what these people are saying:
“I know you are grieving the death of your spouse, I know you’ve told me of the unimaginable pain it’s brought to your life, but I would have preferred your experience than divorce because it’s would have been so much more simple.”
And this hasn’t only happened once. This is a regular occurrence. I’ve heard it from acquaintances, from near strangers, friends. Usually it’s in a dismissive way, sometimes with deep emotion.
I don’t care.
Look, own your pain. Please. If you want to talk to me about how painful your divorce was/is I’m hear to listen. Really. It was a terrible experience for you and I will absolutely be there in any way I can.
We can even talk about both experiences. We can both talk through our pain.
But I will not allow you to compare your divorce to my very very very different experience.
And why would you want to?
3 thoughts on “The Things People Say”
Absolutely different experiences, you are right Ben. Neither is easy but definitely can’t be compared as if it’s a rating scale. Both are not desirable outcomes is what is in common, but after that we each cope in our own way with the uniqueness of the particulars. Individually. I would not like the comparisons either. Hugs
Definitely not the same grief, I agree. There may be some similar emotions, but the differences for each survivor are as unique as the people and relationships were.
You’re too generous. I think people do this because they are narcissistic. Sure, maybe there’s a little empathy in there, but if you *really* get to the root, ill bet there’s plenty of their inner two year old screaming, “How dare you trump my pain with more emotionally catastrophic pain!”
Just my dark take of humanity…also, sorry for using the T-word.